About Us:

Jay & Martha O’Neil are licensed Indiana Realtors® and are the lead agents for Carmel’s premier boutique real estate firm, Sycamore Group Associates. Jay and Martha bring a combined total of over 30 years of Real Estate experience. Jay & Martha’s experience and professional training in marketing and negotiations gives them the upper hand while working for their clients. They know that in today’s hypercompetitive real estate market the traditional real estate marketing model must be drastically and continually revised to stay successful. Having SOLD countless homes, townhouses, and condos throughout the Indy area and watching the changes, they truly know the ins and outs of the real estate market. Jay & Martha have lived in Carmel for over 25 years. They have raised 3 boys and know the school systems, sports and parks programs first hand. When not selling real estate, Jay and Martha enjoy traveling, reading and playing golf. Jay & Martha know Carmel and understand the market. They always keep their client’ best interests at heart, and it shows. Their unique marketing strategies, personal approach with clients, business acumen, ethics, and expertise set them apart from others.

What Our Clients Say:

Before my wife and I arrived in Indiana, we had a very friendly phone call from Martha O’Neil who had sent us e-mails not only about buying a home, but also some information about the Indianapolis & Hamilton County area as well. We had a bad home buying experience before and were a little hesitant about purchasing a new home but the O’Neils were able put us at ease.

They were interested in who we were and what our needs were. When we arrived our first evening in Indianapolis, we were very surprised when we called Jay and he was ready to accommodate us on our very first evening here. Jay & Martha listened to what we needed, wanted and could afford. Most important for us, they also told us what we would need for when we considered reselling.

During the searching process Jay & Martha helped us familiarize ourselves with the local area. We were able to find a home we wanted in just two days. They wrote up an offer and had it accepted the next day. We closed on our house in less than 2 weeks! The loan process was fast and easy plus we feel the O’Neils and their points of contact were able to save us thousands over other mortgage companies. I don't feel that anyone could have done a better job or given better service. The service didn't stop with the signing at closing. Jay & Martha provided us with a list of phone numbers for all the utilities. They’re always available when we have any question. They not only care about making the sale but they also want their customers to be happy and enjoy their new homes.

Jay & Martha O’Neil are two of the most honest and hard working individuals I have had the good fortune to meet. I highly recommend them along with any of the advice that they have given us over the past two years. Anyone who uses their services will definitely appreciate the dedication and help.

Well, simply put, it was nothing short of a pleasure. Truly, you were very pleasant and attentive from the first phone call. I think you e-mailed me listings in my price range within an hour or two and made me feel: 1) comfortable knowing that I could call you whenever I had questions (which is very important from the first-time-home-buyer's perspective); and 2) confident that you were fully representing me and my interests.

I was very pleased with the home I picked and had custom finished for me. I love it! You were very patient with me when picking out all the carpets, hardwood, appliances, tile etc. I referred several other families to you because of the great service that you provided to me. They all rave about the great homes you found them. They appreciated your extensive knowledge. You made all my home buying decisions so simple and easy. You removed the stress! I will continue to recommend you. Thanks again for all your help!

- Courtney Carress

- Larry McMillan